When Do You Need a WMS? Seven Signs and How to Test Them

Seven signs you need a WMS, each with a test you can run this week, plus when a well-kept spreadsheet is still enough for your warehouse.

Innhold

When do you need a WMS? You need one once your stock, your picks or your client billing depend on memory, paper or a spreadsheet that no longer matches what is on the floor. A lagerstyringssystem controls each item’s movement in and out of a site, so the stock record and the shelf stay in step. If you want the definition first, read what a WMS is and how it works.

This guide sets out the signs that a warehouse or tredjepartslogistikk (3PL) business has outgrown its current tools. Each sign comes with a test you can run yourself, and the last section covers the case for waiting. The thresholds are rules of thumb to help you score your own operation, not industry benchmarks.

Stock is also a financial record. UK companies have to keep records of the stock they own and the stocktakes behind the year-end figure, as set out in GOV.UK guidance on company and accounting records. A stock figure that cannot be explained is therefore an accounts problem as well as an operations one. The European Spreadsheet Risks Interest Group keeps a collection of documented spreadsheet error cases, and they show how a sheet that worked for one person can fail quietly once several people edit it.

Sign one: mis-picks that need a second person to check

The first sign is not the error rate. It is that every pick needs a second person to catch the mistakes. Mathew Buttar, Head of Solutions at Clarus, spent nearly 25 years as a warehouse and operations manager, and he describes the paper pick list like this:

“Give somebody a paper pick list and they go and pick all the items, then bring the pallet to you before they wrap it. You run round that pallet and check that what they picked is what the list says. Then they wrap it, label it and dispatch it. So that’s taken two people’s worth of labour to make sure the pick was correct.”

Test: count how many orders in an ordinary week needed a second person to check the pick before dispatch. If that number is anything other than close to zero, the checking is a daily labour cost, and it is hidden in the day.

A WMS does not remove errors. Mathew puts it plainly: “There is not a warehouse in the world that does not have errors. People are people.” What scanning changes is where an error gets caught. In Clarus handheld workflows, a picker who is on a task for one location and scans a different one is told the scan is wrong, and the device shows the location they should be standing in. That stops the wrong location at the shelf. It cannot stop a picker who scans the right location, the right pallet and the right product, then takes a box from the pallet next to it. Check that limit before you trust any scan-based process.

Sign two: stock records that do not match the shelf

For example, the system says forty cases and the shelf holds thirty-four. Someone checks each order by hand, the shortage turns up at the customer’s door, and the stock record stays wrong until the next count.

Test: pick a sample of locations this week, count them, and compare each count with the record. Mathew’s approach to syklisk inventering is to count a fixed sample of pallets every week, measure the error rate in that sample, and apply it to the rest of the warehouse. If a sample cannot be explained by a known cause, such as a late booking or a damaged pallet already logged, treat the records as unreliable until you know why. A full stock check has its own cost. Mathew describes having to stop operations, work overtime, or count on a night shift to do one.

Structured stock checks are easier to run when the counts feed the record directly. JODA Freight, a refrigeration 3PL, moved its stock takes from weeks of work in Excel to a one-day count, and reached 99% stock accuracy by year two, after running in the 90% to 97% range in year one. Read the full JODA Freight story for the detail.

Sign three: you cannot bill clients for work you cannot prove

This is the sign 3PLs feel first. A charge you cannot evidence is a charge you either never raise or raise and then lose in a dispute. Storage moves, handling events and value-added jobs done on a busy day can slip out of the invoice at month end, and nobody notices until the margin is gone.

Test: work out how many hours your team spends building one client invoice by hand, from the records to the figure on the page. Then ask whether anyone could show a client the activity behind every line of last month’s invoice if the client asked.

St John’s Hall Storage, a 3PL, had its Managing Director spend around four days at the end of each month checking invoices that had been re-keyed from the WMS into the accounts package. Clarus cut invoicing time by 90%, and that re-keying is gone. The St John’s Hall story sets out the change.

Clarus includes client billing features, but a billing claim is only worth something once you have seen it work on your own charges. Ask any vendor, Clarus included, to raise a real month of charges from your activity during the demo before you rely on it.

Sign four: a second client or a second site is on the table

A single-client warehouse can run on one set of rules. Taking on a second client means keeping each client’s stock, reporting and charges apart, and a spreadsheet built for one customer rarely survives two. The same applies when a second site opens and stock has to be visible across both.

Test: without a manual reconciliation, can you say how much of each client’s stock sits in each location, and what each client was charged last month? If the answer needs a day of spreadsheet work, the next client will make the problem worse.

Clarus keeps each client’s inventory, reporting and billing isolated within one warehouse, and it can run multiple warehouses and sites from one environment, through multi-warehouse support. Clients can also log in to the kundeportal to see their stock levels, order status and billing summaries, which removes a steady run of “how much stock have I got?” queries from your inbox.

Sign five: traceability you cannot evidence

Traceability becomes urgent when a customer, a retailer, a regulator or an auditor asks for proof. Batch, expiry and serial records have to link to where the goods went, and the answer has to arrive in minutes rather than days. If you handle food, the Food Standards Agency’s guidance on food incidents, product withdrawals and recalls is the place to start.

Test: pick any batch received last quarter and try to answer three questions: which orders it went on, which client it belonged to, and whether any of it is still on the shelf. Time how long that takes. If the answer is “a day” or “we would have to ask someone”, you have this sign.

Mathew describes the recall sequence in practice. You identify what went to which order and which vehicle, but only if the dispatch data was captured at the time. You then put the stock still in the warehouse on hold, so it cannot be allocated to another order, and you stop any pick already on an order that has not left, reallocating that stock to a batch that is clear. Clarus supports this through batch and lot control og sporing av utløpsdato. Campeys of Selby, a food business, now completes product recalls in under five minutes, and it secured BRC Double-A accreditation. See the Campeys of Selby story.

Traceability has a limit. Once a load leaves the back door, the warehouse system cannot control what happens to it. If you run a customs warehouse, HMRC’s application to operate a customs warehouse asks for inventory records, so check those requirements before you assume a spreadsheet will do.

Sign six: volume and SKU count past what one person can hold

Experienced managers can hold a warehouse in their heads for a long time. The signal is that the knowledge sits with one or two people, and when they are off, the site slows down or starts guessing.

Test: ask two people who do not manage the warehouse where a named pallet of one of your slower-moving lines is, and time how long they take to find it. Then ask who could list every order from last month that used a particular batch. If finding a pallet depends on one named person, you have this sign, whatever your order count.

Volume alone does not decide it. A site with a low, steady order count and few SKUs can run on a well-kept spreadsheet. A site with many SKUs and a rising order count tends to feel the strain in its picking and stock checks first.

When an ERP stock module stops being enough

Many businesses start with the stock module in their enterprise resource planning (ERP) system. It is good at telling you how much you own, and that is its job. It does not usually hold where each pallet is, who moved it, or what state it is in on the floor. Mathew describes the split this way: an inventory management system is “a top level view of what stock you have, where it is, and its value”, while the WMS controls each item’s movement through the warehouse, so the inventory system “can trust that the stock levels that it sees” are correct.

Test: ask your ERP stock module where one named pallet is right now, and who last moved it. If you have to walk to the floor to answer, the module is acting as a stock ledger, not a control system. For how the two systems fit together, read ERP vs WMS: what is the difference and which do you need.

When do you not need a WMS yet?

A WMS is not the right answer for every warehouse, and buying one early can make things worse. You probably do not need one yet if you have one client or only your own stock, a low and steady order count, few SKUs, no batch or expiry control, one person who genuinely knows where everything is, and a spreadsheet that still reconciles at every stock take.

In that case, a well-built spreadsheet is the right tool. How to build a stock control spreadsheet that works is a better next read than a software brochure. Mathew’s view of where software fits is useful here: a system “doesn’t necessarily have to do the function. It should complement the function and process of the business that needs it.”

A WMS will not fix a process that nobody follows. If stock is received without being scanned, the system will hold the wrong figures with more confidence than the spreadsheet did. Fix the discipline first, then decide whether the software is needed.

What to do once you recognise the signs

Write the problems down in numbers before you speak to any vendor. For each sign, record how often it happens, how long it takes, and what it costs in labour, lost sales or disputed charges. That list is the start of a business case, and it is what makes a warehouse management system ROI calculation worth doing.

From there, the next pages depend on where you are. For the price range, see WMS cost: a complete pricing guide for UK warehouses. Den typer av lagerstyringssystemer explains the options, and a WMS RFP is how you ask vendors to answer your numbers honestly. The implementation guide covers what happens after you sign.

Clarus pricing starts from £1,000 a month on monthly rolling contracts, with no long-term lock-in. On timing, Mathew says a standard Clarus project should aim to go live within around 12 weeks, because people need time to learn the new way of working. Industry bodies such as CILT UK publish wider guidance on logistics practice if you want context beyond software.

Snakk med en lageransvarlig

Hvis du vurderer ulike alternativer og ønsker å se hvordan et spesialutviklet lagerstyringssystem (WMS) fungerer i praksis, er Clarus verdt å ta en prat med. Vi samarbeider med 3PL-leverandører og distributører over hele Storbritannia for å implementere lagerstyringsprogramvare som tilpasses din driftsmodell – ikke omvendt.

Ta kontakt med teamet vårt å snakke gjennom dine krav.

Spørsmål du kanskje lurer på

Ofte stilte spørsmål

When do you need a WMS in a warehouse?

You need a WMS when stock records, picking or billing depend on memory, paper or a spreadsheet that no longer matches the floor. A common early sign is that every pick needs a second person to check it.

When does a 3PL need a WMS?

A 3PL usually needs one once it runs several clients or sites and must keep each client’s stock, reporting and charges separate and provable. Being unable to evidence a charge is often the first warning.

Do you need a warehouse management system, or is a spreadsheet enough?

A spreadsheet is enough while one person can hold the stock in their head, the order count is low and steady, there is no batch or expiry control, and the records still reconcile at every stock take.

Does a small business or single-site warehouse need a WMS?

Not automatically. Size matters less than the signs. A single-site business with batch control, a rising order count and frequent miscounts can have a real need, while a small, steady operation may not.

When do you not need a WMS yet?

You do not need one yet if you have one client, a steady order count, few SKUs, and a spreadsheet that still matches the shelf at every stock take. A WMS will not fix a process that nobody follows.

Klar til å forenkle lagerdriften din?

Siste innsikt og trender.

Utforsk flere artikler fylt med praktiske ideer, bransjetrender og reelle resultater fra team som bruker moderne systemer for å ligge i forkant.

Future of Warehouse Management System: UK Trends for 3PLs

The future of warehouse management system for UK 3PLs: cloud, API links, AI, robotics and billing, with ready-now trends split from hype.

AS400 Warehouse Management System: A Practical Guide

An AS400 warehouse management system runs on IBM i. Learn what it is, its real risks, and how UK 3PLs plan a move to a cloud WMS.

Swisslog warehouse management system explained

Swisslog's warehouse management system is SynQ, a platform that combines WMS, WCS, MFC and SCADA. Learn what it does and who it suits.